Having had both, the hip is harder from the restrictions angle but then the recovery is a lot shorter, the knee is strong from the word go but the recovery is much longer and the pain is a lot worse than the hip. Both are major surgeries.
Should you go home after a hip or knee replacement?
Dec 22, 2021 · Overall, hip replacement results are better than those for knee replacement. Only about 1 in 10 people who have hip replacement report persistent pain or dissatisfaction after surgery. One in 5 knee replacement recipients say they have continuing pain afterward or are unhappy with the outcome.
Why hip and knee replacements are on the rise?
Mar 11, 2015 · Joint replacement surgeries are complicated procedures. While knee and hip replacements can help alleviate pain and improve function, there are some differences between the two procedures. Dr. Chris Pelt is a joint replacement specialist who will walk you through the similarities and differences between the two surgeries, such as recovery, dislocation and more.
How bad should my knee feel before getting knee replacement?
Jul 28, 2009 · Having had both, the hip is harder from the restrictions angle but then the recovery is a lot shorter, the knee is strong from the word go but the recovery is much longer and the pain is a lot worse than the hip. Both are major surgeries.
Is the hip or knee joint more stable and why?
1, Knee joint is very superficial, while hip is deep. 2, Knee joint is rather larger compared to hip joint. 3, Knee has flat surfaces and precise instrumentation ensure easier cuts than a hip joint. 4, Most knee replacements use cement to fix components and small errors in bone cuts are corrected by use of cement.
What are the benefits of joint replacement surgery?
The benefits of the surgery, mean the potential for relieving pain and improving function, have to be greater than the likely risks that exist when you undergo any procedure, and in particular, with joint replacement.
Is it rare to get anesthesia for joint replacement?
They are exceedingly rare. In fact, the risk of those types of bad things happening with anesthesia or joint replacement is no more and perhaps even less than the risk of them getting in a car accident on the way to the joint replacement center.
Can knee replacement surgery cause bruises?
They tend to get fairly bruised after the surgery. And then most importantly, not just around the time of the surgery, but also for the life of the knee replacement, some patients will describe a more mechanical feel of the knee. They might notice some clicks.
Is joint replacement surgery dangerous?
Besides that, there are other inherent risks of joint replacement surgery. There's a slightly increased risk for blood clots.
Does knee replacement hurt after surgery?
Now, let's look at some unique aspects of knee surgery. Dr. Pelt: So with knee replacement surgery, it is a part of your body that has the effect of gravity. It's downhill from our heart. So knees tend to swell perhaps a little bit more. They tend to get fairly bruised after the surgery.
Is the hip a different joint than the knee?
The hip does perform differently than the knee. It's a different type of joint, it's a ball and socket as opposed to a hinge type of a joint like a knee. So there's different types of soft tissues around it, it's a deeper joint, there's more muscles.
Is joint replacement pain free?
But it may not be completely pain-free. They may still have a little ache or swelling occasionally. They may notice the weather change.
How long does it take for a knee replacement to be bad?
Bad pain because the hand has a gazillion nerve endings. Total knee replacement (pretty bad pain for about 2–3 weeks, limited motion and occasionally sharp pain the next 3 weeks, anticipate pain and limited range of motion for 6–8 months. ) no walker or Canevari’s after 3 weeks. 7 weeks physical therapy.
Why does my hand hurt after knee replacement?
Bad pain because the hand has a gazillion nerve endings. Total knee replacement (pretty bad pain for about 2–3 weeks, limited motion and occasionally sharp pain the next 3 weeks, anticipate pain and limited range of motion for 6–8 months. ) n. Continue Reading.
What is replacement surgery?
Replacement surgery is done to elleviate pain of a diseased joint, be it hip or knee. The damaged joint is replaced with artificial prosthesis so that movements become free and painless. But at the same time these surgeries are technically demanding procedures.
How long do you need a physiotherapist for a knee?
That’s where you need a good physiotherapist - just for the first week, until you get to know the ‘feel’ of what you can do. The difference is the enormous muscle force required to straighten your knee when you are weight bearing, which is all concentrated in a much smaller area than is the case with a hip.
Where is the hip incision made?
The first is due to the position of the incision. In the hip, it is usually made on the side and slightly behind the outer tip if the hip . As hip movements beyond 90 degrees of flexion are not usually encouraged very early on, then not much stretch is put on the fresh incision. In contrast, the incision on.
Why are my knees so painful?
The main reasons I found knees to be more painful is due to 2 main factors: The first is due to the position of the incision. In the hip, it is usually made on the side and slightly behind the outer tip if the hip.
Is hip a knee replacement?
The knee has to balance off-center loads and move side to side. And with a total knee replacement, you are removing a lot of tissue and bone.
What is knee replacement?
But a knee replacement involves releasing ligaments, putting the components onto bone — and then getting things to balance out just right. The ligaments can be damaged or shortened by arthritis, so you really have to make sure the knee is stable. And the joint must flex and rotate.
How long does it take to recover from knee replacement surgery?
People are on crutches for a while, and then their hips feel normal. But it takes six months to a year to recover from total knee surgery, and even then, the knee just doesn't feel normal.
What to expect from knee surgery?
Harvard expert: What you can expect from knee and hip surgery. Your knees and hips are your largest joints. They support your body weight and work in close coordination so that you can run for the bus, squat to lift a child, or play hoops. Over time, many of us experience knee or hip pain, and physical therapy, pain-relief medication, ...
Can a knee replacement help with hip pain?
But for some, knee and hip problems become so intractable that a knee or hip replacement offers the best chance for a return to pain-free mobility.
Does physical therapy help with cartilage?
And, yes, good physical therapy can help if the muscles around the joint are in good shape — but it's tough to get them in good shape, because the joint hurts.
Does knee replacement cause postoperative pain?
The knee has to balance off-center loads and move side to side. And with a total knee replacement, you are removing a lot of tissue and bone. Postoperative pain is higher with knees since the soft tissue affected by the surgery must stretch more than soft tissue around the hip.
Rethinking Rehab After a Hip or Knee Replacement
More than a million Americans will undergo knee or hip replacements this year, according to the National Institutes of Health. Most of them will be 45 or older and experiencing painful joint damage from osteoarthritis.
Rehabilitation for Seniors Aging in Place
Home recovery can be suitable even for those who live alone, according to groundbreaking research by Dr. William Hozack, professor of orthopedic surgery at the Sidney Kimmel Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia, and others.
Weighing Your Options
Still, some patients decide that rehab centers are the best place for them. They may face bigger challenges after replacing both knees or hips at once. Perhaps they live far from family or friends, or are isolated in a walk-up apartment with steep stairs. Mobility might be limited by their age, obesity or other infirmities.
Preparing to Rehab at Home
If you elect to do in-home rehabilitation, how do you make the most of your recovery? After consulting your doctor, try the well-tested advice of those who have already succeeded. Here are four tips from former hip or knee replacement patients who went home after their surgeries:
How long does it take to recover from a hip replacement?
For hip replacement, recovery and rehabilitation generally takes about six weeks. Regular activity and exercise, as directed by a physical therapist, can help that process. Although you may need to make some adjustments, having a painful knee usually doesn’t disrupt the rehabilitation needed after hip replacement.
How long do hip implants last?
The implants used in joint replacements are durable, often lasting for decades. In people who receive a total hip replacement, about 90 to 95 percent receive almost total relief of pain following the surgery. Because of the intricacy of the joint, that number drops slightly for knee replacement to about 80 to 85 percent.
Does hip replacement reduce knee pain?
This is called “referred pain.”. So, in some cases, replacing the hip may decrease pain in the knee — possibly reducing it to a point that it could be managed with nonsurgical treatment, such as physical therapy, thereby making a knee replacement unnecessary.
Can you replace a knee joint with a hip replacement?
While the knee joint can be replaced successfully, the technique to do so may be more complicated and generally requires a longer recovery after surgery than the hip. The difference in surgical complexity is one of the reasons hip replacement usually is recommended before knee replacement.
Is hip replacement more complicated than knee replacement?
Hip replacement surgery is a slightly more straightforward procedure than knee replacement. That’s because the hip is a basic ball-and-socket joint. Therefore, it’s a fairly straightforward process to create and implant parts to replace that joint effectively. In contrast, the knee is a complex joint that allows for a wider range ...
Is dislocation a risk for hip replacement?
Complication rates are similar for hip and knee replacements. Although the risk is low, infection is a possibility following both of these procedures. Complete dislocation is not a risk with the knee, but it can be problem with the hip joint after replacement.
Can you move forward after knee replacement?
Depending on your individual circumstances, you should be able to move forward with the knee replacement procedure any time after that. Joint replacement involves removing parts of an arthritic or damaged joint, and replacing them with metal, plastic or ceramic components that replicate the movements of a healthy joint.
